A new research review, published online in the Annals of Internal
Medicine, seems to dispel the myth that it’s possible to be both obese
and healthy if an individual has normal metabolic markers, like low cholesterol
and low blood pressure.
The review, conducted at the Lunenfeld-Tanenbaum Research
Institute at Toronto’s Mount Sinai Hospital, analyzed eight previous studies
from the past decade. Researchers concluded that obesity consistently carries a
higher risk of cardiovascular issues and premature death.
“The finding of increased risk of death or cardiovascular
events for obese individuals suggests that gaining excess weight is associated
with risk that may accumulate over time, even before metabolic and
cardiovascular signs become apparent in lab tests,” study co-author Ravi Retnakaran,
MD, MSc, FRCP(C), said in a news
The eight studies analyzed by Mount Sinai researchers each
spanned 10 years or more and included a combined 61,386 adults. Approximately nine
percent of the participants studied were considered obese but metabolically
healthy. In other words, those individuals had normal cholesterol levels, as
well as blood pressure and blood sugar readings within the healthy range.
However, despite the normal metabolic readings, the
review found that an obese person had a 24 percent higher risk of experiencing
cardiovascular events (like a heart attack or stroke) or premature death
compared to an individual with normal weight. A person who was overweight, but
not obese, had a 21 percent greater risk.
“[W]e found that obesity stood out as the key risk factor
for premature death from any cause, including cardiovascular events,” study co-author
Bernard Zinman, MD, Senior Investigator at the Lunenfeld-Tanenbaum Research
Institute, said in the release. “That’s true for obese people with so-called
healthy metabolic status as well as obese people with poor metabolic status.”
That’s an important finding from a policy perspective,
says the study’s lead author, Caroline
Kramer, MD, PhD, a post-doctoral fellow at the Institute. The notion that health
care resources don’t need to be directed toward obese individuals whose lab
tests are ‘normal’, she says, is simply mistaken.
“Our message to physicians is that for obese individuals,
normal metabolic status regarding blood pressure, cholesterol and blood glucose
is not protective,” Dr. Kramer notes in the release. “If they can start to lose
weight, that’s a benefit.”
However, this new research may be a step toward putting
that debate to rest. One of the strengths of the latest research review was the
length of the studies included. The risks for premature death became even more
pronounced after 10 years of follow-up (the mean follow-up period of the eight
studies was 11.4 years). Studies which suggested otherwise, Dr. Zinman told The
Toronto Star, simply did not track people long enough.
Being overweight or obese carries numerous health
risks, from back pain, sleep apnea, depression and asthma, to heart
disease, stroke, cancer, and diabetes. According to recent statistics from
the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), more than two-thirds of American
adults aged 20 and up are overweight, and roughly 36 percent are obese.
“We are telling people and doctors that it is not okay to
be obese, even though you don't have metabolic abnormalities,” Dr. Kramer told
CTV News. “This excess of weight still confers increased risk for